Farmer Republican
Conservative farm policy, explained

Regulation and Property Rights

Why the GOP Thinks the Farm Bill Should Include a Strong Energy Title

Farm country grows fuel as well as food. Supporters of the Republican approach say a strong energy title in the farm bill backs rural power, biofuels and farm income, and critics have questions.

Illustration for the farm.FM story “Where’s My Farm Bill?”
Energy and farming share the same horizon in West Texas, and a farm.FM story gets at the humor in that crowded view. Read “Where’s My Farm Bill?” on farm.FM.

What is an energy title?

The farm bill is organized into titles, or sections, and the energy title covers programs for renewable energy and energy efficiency in rural areas. Examples have included support for biofuel production, rural energy systems and efficiency improvements for farms and small businesses. Specific programs and funding change with each bill, so read the current text at Congress.gov.

Programs under this title have often been run through USDA Rural Development, which is where producers can look for current offerings.

The energy title has often been a smaller part of the bill in dollar terms, which is one reason its programs get less attention than commodity support. It still matters to producers who want to install solar on a barn, upgrade grain drying equipment or sell crops to a biofuel plant.

Why do supporters want it strong?

Supporters of the Republican approach tend to frame energy as a farm income and national strength issue. Biofuels create demand for corn, sorghum and other crops, which can support prices. Rural energy projects can bring jobs and lower power bills, and domestic production reduces reliance on foreign supply.

They also favor an all-of-the-above view that includes oil and gas, wind and solar, and biofuels, since Texas, Oklahoma and Colorado producers often have leases tied to several of these. Terms of any lease are worth reading with an attorney.

A hypothetical illustration: a dairy in the Panhandle replaces an old, inefficient cooling system and trims its power bill. Supporters say a program that helps with such upgrades pays back through lower operating costs, which helps a farm survive thin margins.

What does this mean in the Texas Panhandle?

The Panhandle is a place where energy and farming already overlap. Wind farms stand in wheat fields, pipelines cross pastures, and ethanol plants buy sorghum and corn. A producer may be a landowner, a tenant and a lease holder at once.

That is why practical details matter. Questions about easements, reclamation, payment terms and crop damage are real, and the Texas A&M AgriLife Extension service offers educational material on leasing and landowner rights in general terms.

Supporters of the Republican approach also say energy independence is a rural story. Farms and ranches produce fuel crops, host pipelines and wind towers, and consume large amounts of diesel and electricity. A strong domestic energy sector, they argue, supports rural tax bases and school funding.

What do critics say?

Critics argue that biofuel mandates and subsidies raise feed costs for livestock producers, who buy the very corn the plants want. They question the environmental gains of some biofuels and say that land use change can offset the benefits. Others say that renewable programs deserve more weight than supporters give them, while some taxpayer groups say energy support should come from the market.

The climate and cost claims are disputed in the research. Look at analysis from USDA Economic Research Service and CBO, and compare with what advocacy groups claim.

Another disputed point is whether renewable energy support in the farm bill crowds out other priorities. Supporters of a narrower bill say energy money should be limited, while others say it should grow. Both can point to cost scores to make their case.

What should a landowner ask before signing an energy lease?

Do not sign quickly. Ask who is responsible for roads, fences and cleanup, how payments are calculated, how long the lease lasts, and what happens if the company sells the project. Ask what happens to your ability to farm or graze. Hire an attorney who knows energy contracts.

General money planning is covered in this farm finance guide, and equipment questions that come up when energy work crosses your fields are in this tractor and equipment guide.

How can you follow the policy?

Read the House Agriculture Committee and Senate Agriculture Committee summaries, and look at the energy title text itself. Farm groups like the Texas Farm Bureau also share positions.

For a lighter take on rural energy, farm.FM has farm economics and agribusiness and farm news and satire. Over at farm.FM you can also read a farm.FM story on farm energy.

If you are a landowner, keep a file on any energy contact: who called, what they offered and when. Records help later if there is a dispute, and they help your attorney give better advice.

Sources and further reading

Ask locally: A Texas oil, gas and wind lease attorney and your extension agent can help you review any energy agreement.

Related articles